City Cast Pittsburgh logo

What To Do With Leftover Pumpkins in Pittsburgh

Posted on October 29, 2025   |   Updated on October 30, 2025
Francesca Dabecco

Francesca Dabecco

a table of pumpkins at the farm market

Gourd luck recycling your pumpkins! (Francesca Dabecco / City Cast Pittsburgh)

Wondering what to do with your leftover Halloween pumpkins and gourds? Here are some options to avoid rotten jack-o-lanterns on your porch.

🎃 Smash ‘Em Up!

Celebrate the end of the Halloween season at Kamin Science Center’s Great Pumpkin Smash on Nov. 1. Drop your carved pumpkin from a 16-foot height, watch it splatter, and learn the physics behind the crash. Pumpkin-smashers get $5 off admission. Costumes are encouraged!

Or take your decaying pumpkins back to the patch! Shenot Farm in Wexford will let you wreck, roll, and smash your jack-o-lanterns 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., Nov. 1-9.

🐖 🐐 Donate to Pigs & Goats

Feed the herd at Allegheny GoatScape, a team of goats that help control invasive species in the city, by donating your whole, uncut pumpkins. They must be firm, fresh, and mold-free; larger than your palm; and without paint or other decorations.

Pigs like pumpkins too! Donate your uncarved, unpainted pumpkins to Pigsburgh Squealers, a pig rescue at 130 Lampus Lane in Tarentum, until Thanksgiving.

  • Your donation will also benefit your teeth! Polished Dental is running a promotion where you can get discounts if you donate a pumpkin to Pigsburgh Squealers.

🥧 Roast & Eat

Whole, undecorated pumpkins are great in soup or baked goods. They may have been sold as “carving” pumpkins, but they are perfectly edible. (I roast, blend, and freeze mine to use all winter long.) Get ideas with some of our favorite pumpkin treats.

🌱 Compost

If you already compost, cut up your pumpkin and add it to the bin — just be sure to take the seeds out so they don’t sprout.

If you don’t compost at home, the city accepts food waste drop-offs at farmers markets in East Liberty and on the North Side. Pittsburgh Food Policy Council is also running a compost pilot at the Lawrenceville Farmers Market.

Note: Do not eat, compost, or donate pumpkins that’ve been preserved with chemicals, hairspray, or vinegar; or if they have paint, glitter, or other decorations.

Share article

Hey Pittsburgh

Stay connected to City Cast Pittsburgh and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Pittsburgh Life Hacks

See All